Did Hunter x Hunter Deserve a Spot in the Big 3 Instead of Bleach?
Explore the debate surrounding Hunter x Hunter’s potential inclusion in the Big 3 anime series, with fans arguing for its impact and popularity compared to Bleach.
Hunter x Hunter vs. Bleach: A Debate of Impact and Popularity
Hunter x Hunter and Bleach are two highly popular shonen manga series that have garnered a significant following among fans. However, there has been an ongoing debate about whether Hunter x Hunter deserved a spot in the esteemed Big 3 anime series instead of Bleach. In this article, we will explore the arguments made by fans regarding the impact and popularity of these two series.

( Credit to: Sportskeeda )
One side of the debate argues that Hunter x Hunter should have been part of the Big 3 due to its significant impact on the animanga industry. Fans claim that many manga creators drew inspiration from Hunter x Hunter, making it a highly influential series. Additionally, they argue that Hunter x Hunter is objectively better and more popular than Bleach. They believe that the series’ hiatuses prevented it from achieving the recognition it deserved. However, it is worth noting that the Big 3 anime series were determined based on the highest-selling manga series in Weekly Shonen Jump during their peak, and Hunter x Hunter’s hiatuses prevented it from being considered for this title.

( Credit to: Sportskeeda )
On the other side of the debate, supporters of Bleach argue that it had a significant impact on the animanga industry and inspired numerous manga series. They point out that creators of popular series like Jujutsu Kaisen and Demon Slayer have acknowledged being influenced by Bleach. This suggests that Bleach had a larger impact on the industry compared to Hunter x Hunter. It is important to consider the influence a series has beyond its own popularity.
Ultimately, the Big 3 anime series consisted of One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach, each leaving their mark on the world of shonen manga and anime. While there is merit to the argument that Hunter x Hunter deserved a spot in the Big 3 instead of Bleach, it is essential to consider the criteria used for the selection. Hunter x Hunter’s hiatuses prevented it from being considered, and Bleach’s impact on the animanga industry cannot be overlooked. Both series have their own unique qualities and contributions to the genre, making them beloved by fans worldwide.
Fans’ Perspectives on Hunter x Hunter and Bleach
The debate surrounding Hunter x Hunter and Bleach has sparked a range of reactions from fans. Some fans agree that Hunter x Hunter should have been part of the Big 3 instead of Bleach. They argue that Hunter x Hunter’s impact on the animanga industry and its overall quality surpass that of Bleach. These fans believe that Bleach only entered the conversation due to Hunter x Hunter’s hiatuses, which prevented it from achieving its full potential. However, it is important to note that popularity and impact are subjective and can vary among individuals.

( Credit to: Sportskeeda )
On the other hand, there are fans who dismiss the idea that Hunter x Hunter should have replaced Bleach in the Big 3. They argue that Bleach had a significant impact on the animanga industry and inspired many creators. The influence of Bleach can be seen in various manga series, indicating its lasting impact. These fans believe that Bleach rightfully earned its place alongside One Piece and Naruto in the Big 3.
It is important to recognize that opinions on the matter will differ among fans, and there is no definitive answer to whether Hunter x Hunter deserved a spot in the Big 3 instead of Bleach. The debate itself showcases the passion and dedication of fans for these series, highlighting their individual strengths and impact.
Considering the Criteria for the Big 3 Selection
When discussing whether Hunter x Hunter deserved a spot in the Big 3 instead of Bleach, it is crucial to consider the criteria used for the selection. The Big 3 consisted of One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach, chosen based on the highest-selling manga series in Weekly Shonen Jump during their peak. Hunter x Hunter’s frequent hiatuses prevented it from being considered for this title, as the consistent release of new chapters is a significant factor in determining popularity and sales.
Furthermore, it is worth noting that Hunter x Hunter’s popularity soared after the release of the 2011 anime adaptation, which introduced the series to a wider audience. Prior to that, its popularity was relatively lower compared to Bleach. While popularity does not solely determine the quality or impact of a series, it is an important factor to consider when discussing the Big 3.
In conclusion, while there are valid arguments on both sides of the debate, the Big 3 anime series consisted of One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach for specific reasons. Hunter x Hunter’s hiatuses prevented it from being considered, and Bleach’s impact on the animanga industry cannot be disregarded. Ultimately, the Big 3 represents a significant era in shonen manga and anime, with each series leaving a lasting impact on the genre.